Vo vet de co du tham phan
Chanh an Toa an Nhan dan toi cao Nguyen Van Hien:
>> Thu tuong san sang doi thoai truc tiep voi dan
>> Hom nay, QH phe chuan viec VN gia nhap WTO
>> Se co chat van tai cac phien hop Uy ban Thuong vu Quoc hoi
 |
| Chanh an Nguyen Van Hien - Anh: VIET DUNG |
Khong “vo vet” thi “chieu co”!
Dang dan giai trinh truoc QH, chanh an Nguyen Van Hien cho biet nam 2005, toan nganh toa an thieu den 1.116 tham phan, do do nganh da “vo vet”, tan dung luc luong da co va bo nhiem them cac tham phan chua dat yeu cau.
Tuy nhien, du da “vo vet”, song do so luong vu an thu ly tang nen den nay van con thieu 900 tham phan! Rat nhieu dai bieu (DB) QH da to thai do buc xuc. DB Le Van Cuong (Thanh Hoa) chi trich viec “vo vet” nhung nguoi khong du tieu chuan vao doi ngu tham phan nhu vay se dan den xet xu lot toi pham va oan sai.
DB Nguyen Dinh Loc (TP.HCM) khang dinh tha thieu con hon “vo vet” tham phan. Con DB Nguyen Ngoc Tran (An Giang) yeu cau ong chanh an khong nen dung tu “vo vet”, ong nhan manh: “Ong chanh an phai can trong khi dung tu nhu vay”…
Boi roi truoc su phan ung cua cac DB, chanh an Nguyen Van Hien da phai hai lan xin “dinh chinh” khong phai la “vo vet”, ma dung ra la “chieu co mot so truong hop trinh do chuyen mon con yeu mot chut o mot so noi de bo nhiem tham phan roi dong vien, mong anh em hoan thanh nhiem vu”.
Song su “chieu co” do lai tiep tuc lam cac DBQH khong hai long, dat van de ve hau qua cua su “chieu co”: tinh hinh huy an, sua an va oan sai dien ra o nhieu noi. DB Nguyen Van Nhuong (Quang Binh) hoi trong so hon 9.000 vu huy an, sua an trong nam 2005, co bao nhieu vu do nguyen nhan chu quan cua tham phan?
DB Nguyen Thi Hong Xinh (Ba Ria - Vung Tau) doan chac so vu an huy, sua khong dung lai o con so 9.000, vi co rat nhieu nguoi do khong du tien hau toa nen da bo cuoc. Ba Xinh nhan manh tu truoc den nay chua thay toa an tu ky luat tham phan nao, chi khi nao bao chi phat hien roi moi xu ly.
DB Le Van Cuong dat van de du luan ram ran ve nhieu truong hop muc an da duoc quyet dinh truoc khi mo phien toa, dieu do dung khong? Ong Hien len tieng: “Chua bao gio co cong van hay chi thi nao quyet dinh an truoc khi xu, neu tim duoc van ban toi hoan toan chiu trach nhiem”.
Ong Cuong khong hai long, dan ngay vu an tham nhung dat dai tai Do Son (Hai Phong). Tra loi DB Nguyen Van Nhuong (Quang Binh) va DB Le Van Cuong ve viec co nhung vu an da qua het cac cap xet xu ma nguoi dan van keu oan, khong duoc Toa an Nhan dan toi cao xem xet, ong Hien noi “cu chieu theo luat phap, het han thi cu the ma lam”. DB Cuong khong dong y, ong noi tieng keu oan cua nguoi dan chanh an phai tran tro, khong the noi “phap luat qui dinh den dau, toi lam nhu the”.
Ong chanh an o dau?
Theo DB Nguyen Thi Hong Xinh, co nhieu tham phan “co tinh dap len phap luat ma di”, va lay dan chung vu nha 83 Doi Can (Ha Noi) da duoc cac DBQH dat van de qua nam ky hop QH roi ma van chua giai quyet duoc. Ba Xinh hoi: do nang luc tham phan kem hay do “chay an”?
Ong Hien khong tra loi ma dat cau hoi khong hieu vi sao ba Xinh la DB o Ba Ria - Vung Tau ma co nhieu cong van giay to va giam sat mot vu viec tai Ha Noi de chat van chanh an nhu vay! Den day Chu tich QH Nguyen Phu Trong phai nhac ong Hien la phai “het suc cau thi”, “phai lang nghe”, DBQH khong chi la DB cua dia phuong ma con la ca nuoc.
Duoc hoi nganh toa an da chuan bi gi de hoi nhap mot khi VN da gia nhap To chuc Thuong mai the gioi, ong Hien cho biet da de nghi va xin duoc kinh phi 6 ti dong. DB Nguyen Ngoc Tran thiet tha: “Troi oi, van de khong phai la tien dong chi Hien a, van de la con nguoi, la hieu biet”.
DB Nguyen Thi Viet Nhan (Kien Giang) phan nan du chanh an Nguyen Van Hien da gan ket thuc nhiem ky nam nam roi ma van chua mot lan den Kien Giang lam viec voi cac toa dia phuong, khien du luan tai toa an dia phuong hay noi rang “ong ngoi o tren hoai”. Ong Hien thua nhan chua den Kien Giang, chi co cap pho cua ong di, toi day ong moi di!
DB Nguyen Lan Dung (Dac Nong) hoi co nhieu nguoi dan qua het cac cap xet xu roi ma van con cam thay bi oan, co gap duoc ong chanh an khong? Chanh an Hien noi rang san sang, song hien nay 1/3 thoi gian lam viec cua ong la danh cho QH, Trung uong, thoi gian rat ban, “khong the ai cung gap duoc!”.
Sau khi chin DB da chat van nhung khong mot ai hai long, Chu tich QH Nguyen Phu Trong da “gut” lai phan chat van. Phien chat van tuong da ket thuc song DB Nguyen Van Kha (Nam Dinh) chua chiu, xin co y kien. Ong cho biet cac DB “het suc buc xuc” voi noi dung cung nhu thai do tra loi cua ong Hien, va rang vi viec xet xu lien quan den sinh mang tung nguoi dan nen ong de nghi QH “ra nghi quyet ve phan chat van chanh an Toa an Nhan dan toi cao”.
Nhieu DBQH vo tay the hien su dong tinh voi tien le chua tung co trong hoat dong chat van va tra loi chat van tai QH nhu vay.
TRUONG UY
|
De nghi ra nghi quyet ve tra loi chat van ong chanh an Theo Luat ve hoat dong giam sat cua QH, neu DBQH khong dong y voi noi dung tra loi thi co quyen de nghi QH tiep tuc thao luan tai phien hop, dua ra thao luan tai phien hop khac cua QH hoac kien nghi QH xem xet trach nhiem doi voi nguoi duoc chat van. QH ra nghi quyet ve viec tra loi chat van va trach nhiem cua nguoi bi chat van khi xet thay can thiet. Ben hanh lang QH, TS luoc ghi mot so y kien xung quanh van de nay.
DB Nguyen Van Kha (Nam Dinh): Toi da can cu vao Luat giam sat de dua ra kien nghi ay, du biet rang day la viec chua co tien le. Nghe chanh an tra loi thi thay ong da khong khiem ton, khong tu nhan trach nhiem ve nhung van de con ton tai trong nganh. Loi le cua ong, xin noi thang, co cho nhu ngoai duong pho chu khong phai cua mot chinh khach tra loi truoc QH, truoc cu tri ca nuoc. DB Nguyen Van Nhuong (Quang Binh): Toi thay phan tra loi chat van cua ong Hien la thieu khiem ton, khong cau thi khien nhieu DB khong hai long. Vi vay toi hoan toan dong tinh voi de nghi cua DB Kha. Do la viec da duoc luat dinh va no cung nham lam cho nguoi tra loi chat van rut kinh nghiem, lam tot hon trong trach cua minh. DB Tran Van Kiet (Vinh Long): Chanh an Nguyen Van Hien da khong tap trung vao cau chat van cua DBQH de tra loi ma chi trinh bay theo suy nghi cua ca nhan dong chi chanh an. Theo cam nhan cua nhieu DBQH, trong do co toi, chanh an Hien da tra loi khong dung trong tam va co gi do hoi xem thuong DBQH. Nhieu DBQH da bay to su bat dong voi y kien tra loi cua chanh an, cho rang qua phan tra loi ay duong nhu dong chi chua du nang luc lam chanh an. DB Nguyen Ngoc Tran (An Giang): Doi voi nganh toa an, mot tu cung phai the hien chuan muc, boi mot tu noi ra anh huong toi xet xu rat nhieu. Chanh an noi co tham phan cung di “vo vet”, noi nhu the lam sao chap nhan duoc. Hay dong chi noi luat cua nuoc ngoai co be day hang tram nam, VN minh chi co may chuc nam... Vay xin hoi Bo luat Hong Duc o dau, roi luat cua trieu Nguyen nhu the nao? Toi thay dong chi chanh an noi nhu the la kho chap nhan. Toi khong ro lam noi dung nghi quyet ma DB Nguyen Van Kha de nghi nhung toi dong y nen co mot ket luan cua QH ve viec chanh an tra loi khong nghiem tuc. DA TRANG - N.V.HAI thuc hien |
