Hang trieu USD bi rut ruot lang phi

Du an tang cuong nang luc giao thong Ha Noi:

24 trieu USD di vay ODA de “ tang nang luc” cho giao thong Ha Noi, nhung du an da gay qua nhieu buc xuc cho du luan boi su lang phi, that thoat va khong hieu qua.

Vua duoc xay dung hang chuc trieu dong nhung “giot nuoc” dau duong Cat Linh da bi pha bo gay that thoat lon

Moi day, mot phan su that cua du an, do Ban QLDA GTDT (So GTCC Ha Noi) lam chu dau tu, da “phoi bay” khi thanh tra chinh phu co ket luan chinh thuc. Du luan van tiep tuc dat nhieu cau hoi xung quanh du an nay!

Tu van: Bo thau 2 trieu USD, ky hop dong 1,4 trieu USD va thanh toan 2,4 trieu USD!

Khuat tat cua du an (DA) tang cuong nang luc giao thong HN xuat hien ngay tai cac hop dong tu van. Gia tri goi thau tu van cua DA trong ke hoach dau thau duoc Thu tuong Chinh phu phe duyet la 1,4 trieu USD. Nhung khi bo thau, nha tu van Louis Berger & Electrowat da bo gia 2,046 trieu USD (la gia thap nhat). Dang le ra chu dau tu phai to chuc dau thau lai, nhung khong hieu sao chu dau tu lai “dam phan” voi nha thau.

Ket qua la hop dong duoc ky ket co gia tri 1.399. 943 USD. (trong do hop dong tron goi 1,218 trieu USD va hop dong theo thoi gian 181.339 USD). Dang khen thay khi chu dau tu bo ra hang chuc trieu dong to chuc dau thau de cuoi cung tiet kiem cho Nha nuoc 57 USD (800.000 dong).

Nghiem trong hon, chi voi viec phat sinh nang cap khoang 3km duong (1,5 km hanh lang Tran Quang Khai va 1,5 km hanh lang Tay Son) va xay dung hao ky thuat cua 2 hanh lang nay nhung chu dau tu da “hao phong” bo sung hop dong tu van them 1,03 trieu USD ( bang 70% hop dong tu van toan bo du an).

Nhu vay thay vi hop dong tu van 1,399 trieu USD ban dau, cuoi cung tong gia tri hop dong tu van da len den 2,43 trieu USD!? Tu van da duoc thanh toan 2,365 trieu USD. Hien tren 65.000 USD chua duoc thanh toan.

Cung cap thiet bi: Mua xe “an choi” danh cho canh sat giao thong

Nhieu thiet bi map mo nguon goc Sau nhieu truc trac va ca nhung dieu chinh lon, cuoi cung chu dau tu da chon duoc nha thau la Cty Tyco lap dat he thong den tin hieu giao thong voi gia tri hop dong la 2,497 trieu USD. Khi thuc hien goi thau den tin hieu, nha thau da “don” nhieu thiet bi khong ghi xuat xu nuoc san xuat voi gia tri len den 44.566 USD nhu: Cap tin hieu 30.800 USD, tu dieu khien: 13.700USD. Ben canh do 3 bo nap dien cua may do toc do va 4 may dem xe tu dong tri gia theo hop dong la 28.545 USD khong ghi ten nuoc san xuat. Day la so thiet bi do Cty Xay dung va thuong mai Alex cung cap. Nha thau bat hop tac Doan thanh tra yeu cau cac nha thau: Cty Cong trinh giao thong 3, Cty xay dung cong trinh giao thong 230, Cty TNHH 75, Cty Tay Ho, Cty quan ly va sua chua duong bo 234 (voi tong gia tri da thuc hien 12,6 ty dong) bao cao bang van ban ket qua thuc hien, nhung cac nha thau da “phot lo”. “Bo hoang” gan 1 ty dong Gan mot ty dong tien dai phan cach cung Newjersey tren hanh lang Le Duan bi phoi nang tu nhieu nam nay. Theo ket luan thanh tra, nha thau duc 1.144 cau kien be tong voi tri gia gan 1,4 ty dong de lap dat tren duong Le Duan. Hien co 713 cau kien (tri gia 855 trieu dong) bi xep xo. Tren 400 cau kien vua duoc dung cho du an duong Lac Long Quan. Ban QLDA: Vung tay qua tran Tong so tien da trich chi phi cho BQLDA la 3,382 ty dong. Trong do tien luong, cong, phu cap la 1,26 ty dong. Tuy nhien theo thong tu 07 cua Bo Xay dung thi BQLDA chi duoc chi khoang 2 ty dong. Nhu vay BQLDA da vung tay qua tran tren 1,3 ty dong.

Theo ke hoach dau thau duoc thu tuong phe duyet thi phan mua sam thiet bi co tong tri gia la 4,17 trieu USD (gom 5 goi thau). Nhung khi thuc hien, Ha Noi lai xin bo sung thanh 5,83 trieu USD.

Trong goi thau A co 6 goi nho (tu A1 den A6): Mua sam thiet bi cho canh sat giao thong (CSGT). Xin de cap den goi thau A6: Mua sam 20 xe mo to 175cc. Vi khong co nha thau tham gia chao thau nen chu dau tu co thu moi mua sam.

Lan 1: Co 3 nha thau gui thu chao hang (trong do co Cty Nguyen Giao). Tuy nhien gia chao cao (gia thap nhat la 12.000 USD/xe) nen khong duoc chap thuan.

Lan 2, chu dau tu gui thu den 7 nha thau (3 nha thau cu va 4 nha thau moi). Cty Nguyen Giao trung thau: Loai xe Rebel 175cc san xuat tai My, gia 5.800 USD/xe (tong gia tri 20 xe la 116.000 USD). Dieu la lung la truoc do da tung chao hang loai xe 175CC voi gia 12.000 USD/xe, nhung chi sau do it ngay, gia xe cung chinh Cty Nguyen Giao chao ban da giam di mot nua, con 5.800 USD/xe (?)

Chua dung o do, nhung chiec xe xuat xu tu My theo hop dong da duoc chuyen hoa thanh xe san xuat tai Nhat Ban. Xe co dong co tu 175cc da duoc doi thanh xe 250cc voi gia khong doi (?). Dac biet, nhung chiec xe an choi nay (mau den) sau do da duoc son lai, gan them coi u, can truoc, thung gan ben hong, gan chu “Police”... va bien thanh xe chuyen dung cua CSGT.

Goi thau xay lap: Rut ruot nhieu ty dong

Phan xay lap gom 8 goi thau (15 trieu USD). Tai cac goi thau hanh lang Tran Quang Khai, hanh lang Bach Mai, cac tuyen pho co... phan chi phi phu tro, chi phi khac da duoc tinh trong phan “ cac yeu cau chung”, nhung cac nha thau van dua vao don gia chi tiet len den 1,35 ty dong.

Doan thanh tra de nghi giam tru quyet toan phan chi phi nay. Hon the, tai ho so trung thau goi Tran Quang Khai, nha thau con dua chi phi phuc vu tu van 500 trieu dong. Doan thanh tra cung de nghi giam tru.

Nghiem trong hon, cac nha thau con “rut ruot” cong trinh 3,8 ty dong (gom 632 tan nhua Bitum, 16,6 tan nhua trong, 35,64 tan nhu tuong). Doan thanh tra de nghi giam tru khi quyet toan.

Tai goi thau cai tao cac tuyen pho co, nhieu thiet bi nhu: Rao chan cho nguoi di bo, bien bao, gach be tong tu chen... tri gia 439 trieu dong chua he duoc lap dat nhung duoc nha thau de nghi thanh toan. De xay ra su lang phi lon nhu vay ai se phai chiu trach nhiem?

Tuy nhien, nhung so lieu tren moi dung tren so sach. Tai hien truong, qua khoan 47 vi tri de kiem tra be tong nhua (tren tat ca cac goi thau) thi da thay thieu hut 340 m3 vua lot, 180 m3 be tong, 63 m3 cat vang. So bo khoi luong bi thieu hut so voi thiet ke len den 445 trieu dong.

Voi cung cach thi cong, kiem tra, giam sat nhu vay chac chan so vat lieu bi “rut ruot” thuc te con co the tang hon gap nhieu lan. Ai se chiu trach nhiem ve viec nay? Du luan dang nong long cho quan diem xu ly cua co quan chuc nang.

Phung Suong

Thanh tra Chinh phu con chua “so” den nhieu dau viec -Chua lam ro vi sao hop dong tu van cho toan bo du an chi co 1,4 trieu USD nhung khi du an phat sinh them mot so hang muc thi hop dong tu van duoc bo sung them 1 trieu do la. -Viec tham be tong do (dat hon nhieu so voi be tong den) de to chuc cho lan xe tho so nhung den nay khong to chuc giao thong duoc vi trai Luat. Gay lang phi cho Nha nuoc len den nhieu ty dong, va ai se phai chiu trach nhiem? - Nhieu nut giao thong duoc dung “luon”, “trach”, xay dung dao xuyen, trong hoa...len den hang ty dong nhung sau mot thoi gian su dung ngan da phai do bo. Vay lang phi la bao nhieu, don vi nao phai chiu trach nhiem? -Viec thay the 23 nut den giao thong dang hoat dong tot bang nhung nut den giao thong moi gay lang phi hang ty dong. Hon the viec lap dat 78 nut den moi den nay van do dang, mot so nut den lap xong nhung khong the hoat dong duoc. Vay nguyen nhan do dau, thiet hai cho Nha nuoc la bao nhieu? van chua duoc lam ro... Hanh Ngan