Chanh an Toa an nhan dan toi cao Nguyen Van Hien Toi dut khoat khong chi dao duyet an
Tat ca cac cau tra loi cua Chanh an Toa an nhan dan toi cao Nguyen Van Hien tai phien chat van sang qua deu bi dai bieu Quoc hoi phan bac. Chu tich Quoc hoi Nguyen Phu Trong hon mot lan phai nhac ong Hien: "Can het suc cau thi, lang nghe, phai phat bieu ve trach nhiem cua minh". DB Nguyen Van Kha (Nam Dinh) con yeu cau Quoc hoi phai ra mot nghi quyet rieng ve viec tra loi chat van cua Chanh an Toa an nhan dan toi cao.
DB Nguyen Van Nhuong (Quang Binh) hoi: "Trong bao cao cua Chanh an thi nam 2006 co khoang 9.697 ban an bi huy, sua. Co bao nhieu ban an phai huy, sua do nguyen nhan chu quan la tham phan; cac tham phan chu toa cac phien toa nay bi xu ly the nao ?". Chanh an Nguyen Van Hien: "Trong bao cao cua Toa an nhan dan toi cao gui cac dai bieu, chung toi da noi ro roi. Tuy muc do, neu nang luc yeu kem thi xu ly theo nang luc yeu kem, neu do thieu tinh than trach nhiem thi xu ly theo thieu tinh than trach nhiem, neu do tieu cuc thi xu theo tieu cuc". DB Nguyen Thi Hong Xinh chat van gay gat: "6 giai phap dong chi noi de nang cao chat luong xet xu qua cu, ro rang nganh toa an van thuc hien ma an oan, sai van nhieu. Toi hoi ranh gioi nao de phan biet an oan sai do nang luc cua tham phan kem va do chay an?". Chanh an Nguyen Van Hien tra loi bang giong cung gay gat khong kem: "Dong chi co giai phap nao tot hon chung toi xin nghe, trinh do chung toi chac chua nghi them duoc. Con an oan, sai truong hop nao do nang luc, truong hop nao do chay an phai can cu vao so luong tong hop tung vu cu the... Muon ky luat nguoi ta cung phai theo Phap lenh Tham phan, Phap lenh Cong chuc chu khong phai cu sai la ky luat ngay duoc".
Chu tich Quoc hoi Nguyen Phu Trong phai "do" cho ong Hien: "Dong chi Chanh an het suc luu y trong cach tra loi, phai thay trach nhiem cua minh da roi phan tich cai gi thi tuy dong chi". Tuy nhien, cac cau tra loi tiep sau do cua ong Hien van o tinh trang tuong tu khien cac dai bieu khong hai long. DB Le Van Cuong (Thanh Hoa) hoi: "Cac ban an thuong duoc quyet dinh truoc khi mo phien toa, qua hinh thuc duyet an. Theo Chanh an co hay khong ?". Chanh an Nguyen Van Hien qua quyet: "Toi la Chanh an Toa an nhan dan toi cao, va ke ca Hoi dong tham phan Toa an nhan dan toi cao chua bao gio co mot cong van, chi thi yeu cau cac dia phuong phai duyet an. Dut khoat la chung toi khong co. Nhung dung la voi nhung vu an phuc tap, anh huong den chinh tri, trat tu xa hoi, voi tinh than trach nhiem mot so lanh dao dia phuong nghe Hoi dong xet xu, nghe tham phan bao cao nhung khong quyet dinh muc an va toi danh". DB Cuong: "Vu an Do Son la mot dien hinh. Ngay trong nganh tu phap cung co thong nhat truoc, neu o phien toa co thay doi lon thi phai hop lai. Chinh the nen cac tham phan rat ngai tranh tung tai toa vi trinh do kem, so cac luat su lam ro van de khien ban an khac di. Trach nhiem cua Chanh an the nao ?". Cau hoi nay khong duoc ong Hien tra loi. Tuyet Nhung |
|||
|
Viet Bao
|
