Vietnam Airlines That thoat hang tram trieu dong trong cac du an tin hoc

Theo tinh toan ban dau that thoat trong vu nay khoang hon 300 trieu dong.

Tu nam 1995-2002, Vietnam Airlines da xay dung va thuc hien 25 du an cong nghe thong tin (CNTT) voi tri gia 51,2 ty dong va 2,1 trieu USD. Qua ket qua thanh tra 6 chuong trinh, du an, Thanh tra Chinh phu da phat hien hang loat sai pham.

Dien hinh nhat la du an mua 241 may tinh cua Cong ty Nhat Quang va 74 may cua Cong ty CMC. Mac du doan thanh tra da yeu cau Vietnam Airlines cung cap cac tai lieu co lien quan den viec to chuc moi thau, xet thau doi voi 2 goi thau mua so may tinh nay, nhung den thoi diem thanh tra don vi nay van chua cung cap duoc tai lieu.

Tuy nhien, qua xem xet mot so tai lieu duoc cung cap lien quan den cac hop dong mua 241 may tinh cua Cong ty Nhat Quang va hop dong mua 74 may tinh cua Cong ty Truyen thong CMC da cho thay khi thuc hien viec cung cap may tinh cho Vietnam Airlines thi Cong ty Nhat Quang da mua lai cua nhieu don vi may tinh khac trong nuoc nhu Cong ty FPT, Cong ty TNHH may tinh The Trung…

Cac chung nhan xuat xu may tinh ma Cong ty Nhat Quang da cap cho Vietnam Airlines la cac chung chi xuat xu do phia nuoc ngoai cap cho cac Cong ty FPT, Cong ty TNHH may tinh The Trung va cap theo tung lo voi so luong rat lon, noi dung ghi chung chung, khong ro rang. Do do chua co du co so va can cu de xac dinh chinh xac ve xuat xu cua so may tinh ma Cong ty Nhat Quang da ban cho Vietnam Airlines. Ngoai ra, ben canh viec dau thau mua cac lo may tinh nay, Vietnam Airlines da xay dung gia tran va chon doi tac chua hop ly.

Doi voi hop dong bao tri phan mem AMASIS voi Cong ty IFR (Cong ty San xuat phan mem cua Phap) qua kiem tra cung phat hien hang loat sai pham. Nam 1996, hang Airbus co tai tro cho Vietnam Airlines mot so thiet bi tin hoc kem theo he thong phan mem de quan ly vat tu may bay A320 (goi la he thong AMASIS).

Nam 1999, de khac phuc su co Y2K doi voi phan mem AMASIS, Truong ban Cong nghe thong tin cua Vietnam Airlines da ky hop dong voi Cong ty IFR cua Phap, theo do Cong ty IFR cong nhan quyen su dung phan mem AMASIS cua Vietnam Airlines, va thoa thuan hang nam IFR se bao tri phan mem nay va dao tao nhan vien cua Vietnam Airlines. Vietnam Airlines se phai tra cho IFR mot khoan phi hang nam.

Tuy nhien, qua thanh tra da phat hien chua he co bat cu van ban nao the hien su dong y do va cung chua thay co van ban the hien hop dong nay da duoc Tong Giam doc Vietnam Airlines phe duyet. Theo bao cao cua Vietnam Airlines, tren thuc te cuoi nam 1999, Cong ty IFR co cu chuyen gia sang de khac phuc su co Y2K cho phan mem AMASIS va da dao tao nhan vien cho Vietnam Airlines voi muc chi phi khac phuc su co Y2K va phi bao tri nam 1999 la hon 220.000Fr.

Tu nam 1999 - 2001, phia Phap da de nghi Viet Nam Airlines thanh toan 404.119,24Fr gom khoan chi phi khac phuc su co Y2K cua nam 1999, phi bao tri cua nam 2000 va 2001. Sau khi nhan duoc de nghi cua phia Phap, Vietnam Airlines chua dong y tra so tien tren vi cho rang, viec xac dinh so tien do la qua cao, bat hop ly va can phai dam phan lai.

Thoi diem do, Vietnam Airlines da dong y cho thanh lap doan cong tac sang Phap de dam phan lai. Tuy nhien, dieu het suc kho hieu la trong luc chua to chuc dam phan lai voi phia Phap, mot so ca nhan co trach nhiem lai sot sang mang toan bo so tien tren tra cho doi tac nuoc ngoai mac du biet chi phi tren la qua cao, bat hop ly!

Yeu cau hang My, Nhat, nhap ve hang Dai Loan, Thai Lan

Viec thuc hien mua sam trang bi tin hoc nam 1996 theo Hop dong so 196/UTHK/TB va so 090496 ngay 13/5/1996. Sau khi mo thau, Cong ty Digital da trung thau voi tri gia goi thau 2.435.234 USD. Hop dong nay da duoc thuc hien va thanh toan tien trong nam 1998, tuy nhien den thoi diem thanh tra, Vietnam Airlines van chua cung cap day du cac tai lieu co lien quan cho Doan thanh tra.

Theo ket qua mo thau cua to xet thau thi mot so thiet bi ma Digital chao co gia cao hon so voi gia chao cua IBM la 16.276 USD (ngoai ra, Vietnam Airlines con phai thanh toan 5% thue nhap khau, va 0,5% phi uy thac tren tong gia tri thiet bi). The nhung, phia Vietnam Airlines van nhat tri chon Digital trung thau va da ky hop dong voi doi tac nay.

Mat khac, theo yeu cau dat ra khi to chuc chon thau thi phan lon cac thiet bi duoc mua sam phai co nguon goc tu My, Nhat Ban, thuc te khi nhan lo thiet bi nay deu khong co giay chung nhan xuat xu. Theo cac tai lieu kem theo ho so thiet bi cho thay phan lon thiet bi cung cap ghi la san xuat tai Dai Loan, Han Quoc va Thai Lan.

Du an dau tu he thong DCS tai san bay Tan San Nhat va khu vuc Gia Lam voi tong kinh phi dau tu cua du an 850.999USD cung co nhung sai pham. Ve dau tu cung cap va lap dat trang thiet bi cua he thong DCS san bay Tan San Nhat trong nam 1999 va 2000 duoc thuc hien theo hinh thuc dau thau va Chi nhanh Cong ty FPT tai TP Ho Chi Minh da trung thau goi thau cung cap may tinh, may chu va phan mem cua he thong.

Theo nhu quyet dinh phe duyet cua HDQT thi trang thiet bi tai goi thau nay co xuat xu la My. The nhung, trong hop dong mac du gia ca van duoc giu nguyen nhung xuat xu cua so thiet bi nay lai tu Australia va Singapore. Tham chi, khi thuc hien hop dong, phia nha thau da giao hang loat thiet bi nhu man hinh, chuot, ban phim co xuat xu tu Trung Quoc, Thai Lan. Ngoai ra, hang loat du an khac duoc dau tu hang tram trieu dong nhung sau do da bi that thoat, lang phi.

That thoat hang tram trieu dong, nhieu du an chua quyet toan duoc

Theo bao cao cua Vietnam Airlines ve tinh hinh quyet toan von dau tu cac du an dau tu mua sam trang thiet bi tin hoc tu nam 1995 den nam 2002 voi tong muc dau tu duoc phe duyet hon 99 ty dong nhung cho den thoi diem thanh tra co toi hon 24 ty dong van chua quyet toan duoc.

Qua thanh tra 6 du an dau tu he thong tin hoc tai Vietnam Airlines, mac du con mot so ho so tai lieu co lien quan Vietnam Airlines van chua duoc tap hop va cung cap day du cho doan thanh tra, nhung buoc dau doan thanh tra da xac dinh chenh lech ve gia tri la 353 trieu dong.

Doan thanh tra da xac dinh: Cong tac quan ly, su dung tai san tai day da co nhung bieu hien buong long quan ly, nhung so lieu tong hop chi phi dau tu ve gia tri tai san va hien tai trang thiet bi tin hoc da dau tu mua sam phan anh tren so sach ke toan cung nhu tren cac bao cao quyet toan cua Vietnam Airlines la khong chinh xac va khong duoc quan ly hach toan day du, chua co du co so va can cu de dam bao duoc do tin cay.

Tren day chi la dot thanh tra 6 trong so 25 du an dau tu he thong tin hoc tai don vi nay nhung da he lo ra hang loat sai pham nghiem trong trong linh vuc nay. Chinh vi vay, vua qua, thuc hien y kien chi dao cua Thu tuong, Thanh tra Chinh phu da quyet dinh lap doan thanh tra de thanh tra lam ro noi dung dau tu mua sam he thong tin hoc hien co nhieu khuat tat tai don vi nay.

(theo CAND)