Gioi chuyen mon nhan dinh ve diem san

Ngay mai, 12.8, hoi dong xac dinh diem san cua Bo GD-DT se nhom hop de co quyet dinh ve muc diem san nam 2005 lam co so cho cac truong cong bo diem chuan trung tuyen. Vay nam nay diem san bao nhieu la vua?

TS Tran Hanh - Hieu truong Truong DHDL Lac Hong, Dong Nai: 15 diem la vua

De ra de hay kho la viec cua Bo GD-DT, con chon nguoi vao hoc dai hoc thi can co trinh do trung binh tro len. Vi vay, theo toi, diem san nen lay 15 diem (khong can phan biet khoi thi) la vua, tren co so  binh quan moi mon phai dat 5 diem tro len.

Mot chuyen gia Bo GD - DT: Khong nen chi can cu vao diem thi cua thi sinh

Theo toi, khi dinh diem san phai can cu vao hai yeu to. Ve mat ly thuyet thi diem san se la diem trung binh cua ky thi, tuy nhien neu chi dua vao yeu to nay chua du, ma phai can cu vao yeu to xa hoi, vung, mien. Vi du: doi voi phia Bac nguon tuyen doi dao hon phia Nam, chat luong cung cao hon do do viec diem san la bao nhieu cung it tac dong toi viec tuyen sinh cua cac truong. Tuy nhien, doi voi  phia Nam nhat la khu vuc dong bang song Cuu Long thi  nguon tuyen rat kho khan, neu muc diem san qua cao se khong co nguoi di hoc.

Diem trung binh cua ky thi khong co nghia la 15 diem ma tuy theo muc do kho de cua de thi nam do. Vi du: nam 2001 diem trung binh la 11 - 12 diem, nam 2003 cung vay. Nam 2004 diem trung binh nhich len la 14. Con nam nay theo toi voi muc de thi nhu vay diem trung binh co the la 15.

PGS-TS Pham Ba Phong - Hieu truong Truong DHDL Yersin, Da Lat: Khong nen cao hon nam ngoai

Voi chi tieu 840 sinh vien, truong chung toi khong to chuc thi tuyen nhung den nay da co vai chuc TS trung tuyen dot 1 vao truong (se hoan tat nop don truoc 20.8). Theo toi, diem san nam nay khong nen cao hon nam ngoai!

TS Nguyen Dung - Hieu truong Truong DHDL Van Lang, TP.HCM: Khong nen qua 15 diem

Dinh diem san chung cho toan quoc nhung cung can luu y dac diem cua cac vung, mien, trong do co mot so khu vuc kho khan nhu o dong bang song Cuu Long. Theo toi, mac du nam nay o mot so mon thi co diem cham rat cao nhung diem san cung khong nen qua 15 diem.

Ong Phan Huy Phu - Hieu truong Truong DH DL Thang Long: Khong nen lay qua 15 diem

Theo toi, diem san khong nen lay qua diem trung binh la 15. Day la diem toi thieu de vao dai hoc. Diem san chi nen xem la mot nguong de thi sinh (TS) duoc xet tuyen chu khong phai la TS nao dat diem san la cung dau dai hoc. Do do khong nen lay diem san qua cao. Chi nen lay muc diem ma nguon tuyen cao hon chi tieu it nhat 10-20% hoac co the cao hon. Thuc te thi mac du nguon tuyen co thua nhung nhieu truong van co the lay thieu chi tieu do TS khong muon hoc. Cho nen, theo toi Bo  chi nen dinh mot muc diem nao do de xac dinh TS do du trinh do dao tao, phan con lai  de tu xa hoi dieu tiet.

Vu Tho - Nhut Quang  (thuc hien)