GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet TS quay clip tieu cuc dang khen
Tags: GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet, Bac Giang, Luc Nam, Doi Ngo, THPT Dan, chu tich hoi dong, hoi dong thi, thiet bi quay, Luat Giao Duc, thi tot nghiep, thi sinh, vi pham, tieu cuc, xu ly, Clip
- "Ve cong, toi khen cac thi sinh do trung thuc va dung cam. Vi neu cac em cung im lang chep “phao” ma nguoi cua hoi dong thi dua vao thi cac em co the do, tham chi do voi diem cao." GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet chia se.
Xung quanh viec sai pham trong to chuc thi tot nghiep tai hoi dong thi truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo (Luc Nam, Bac Giang) dang gay xon xao du luan, PV TS da co cuoc trao doi voi GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet.
- Thua ong, khi xem clip ghi lai canh lon xon trong phong thi tai hoi dong thi truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo (Luc Nam, Bac Giang) vua qua, ong co suy nghi gi?
GS. Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Cac giam thi o hai phong thi da vi pham quy che thi mot cach nghiem trong. Viec dua dap an vao cho rat nhieu thi sinh nhu vay chung to day co kha nang la mot vu lam trai co to chuc.
Viec lam nay co the noi la rat dang xau ho, trong khi thi sinh nam nay lam de thi Van ban ve chu de doi tra, thi day la mot hanh dong doi tra trang tron, khong the nao chap nhan duoc.
- Thua ong, dua vao dau ong cho rang su viec lon xon vua qua tai hoi dong thi truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo co kha nang la co to chuc?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Neu khong co to chuc thi khong the lam nhu vay duoc. Phai co nguoi dua de ra ngoai, roi lam dap an, sau do pho to va chuyen hang chuc ban dap an vao phong cho thi sinh chep.
Vi vay, viec nay can phai xu ly nghiem. Truoc het, phai xu ly nhung nguoi truc tiep vi pham va lanh dao hoi dong thi. Tiep theo la xu ly lanh dao giao duc dia phuong, tu Phong GD huyen den So GD-DT.
- Thi sinh dem thiet bi quay vao phong thi ghi lai canh gian lan trong thi cu va to giac thi trong truong hop nay lieu co cong hay co toi, thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Viec hoc sinh mang thiet bi quay vao phong thi la vi pham quy che ro rang. Nhung chuyen gi cung vay, khi xu ly, phai xem xet “cong” va “toi”.
Ve cong, toi khen cac thi sinh do trung thuc va dung cam. Vi neu cac em cung im lang chep “phao” ma nguoi cua hoi dong thi dua vao thi cac em co the do, tham chi do voi diem cao.
Nhung cac em nay da khong chap nhan chuyen gian doi, da quay video va phan anh lai, nho do ma co quan quan ly giao duc biet duoc nhung sai pham dang dien ra de rut kinh nghiem chi dao nhung ky thi tiep theo.
- Giua cong va toi thi ben nao nang hon, thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Mang trang thiet bi trai phep vao phong thi thi bi dinh chi thi, tuc la khong duoc cong nhan ket qua thi cua mon thi co vi pham. Nhung ket qua thi cua cac thi sinh khac o hai phong thi nay cung kho co the duoc cong nhan.
Con viec cac em do neu bang chung to cao sai pham thi co loi cho cong tac giao duc chu khong co hai. Binh thuong, cong nay dang duoc khen thuong. Boi vay, viec xem xet truong hop nay phai het suc can nhac, khong the noi mot cach may moc, don gian duoc.
- Nhieu y kien cho rang, thiet bi quay cua thi sinh khong co chuc nang xem lai video, khong co thiet bi phat song vi vay khong the phuc vu cho loi ich cua thi sinh. Vay thiet bi nay co bi coi la mot thiet bi vi pham quy che khong thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Quy che thi da neu ro nhung thiet bi nao duoc phep mang vao phong thi. Mang nhung thiet bi khong duoc phep la vi pham quy che.
- Thua ong, neu nhung can bo va giam thi trong clip duoc xac dinh la to chuc giai de, nem bai cho thi sinh thi lieu day co phai la toi danh lam lo bi mat quoc gia?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Theo toi, day la hanh vi vi pham Luat Giao duc.
Khoan 2 Dieu 75 Luat Giao duc quy dinh mot trong nhung hanh vi nha giao khong duoc lam la “gian lan trong tuyen sinh, thi cu, co y danh gia sai ket qua hoc tap, ren luyen cua nguoi hoc”. Cac nhan vien duoc phan anh trong video clip da vi pham quy dinh nay.
Ve huong xu ly vi pham thi khoan 1 Dieu 118 Luat Giao duc da quy dinh ro: “Nguoi nao co mot trong cac hanh vi sau day thi tuy theo tinh chat, muc do vi pham ma bi xu ly ky luat, xu phat vi pham hanh chinh hoac truy cuu trach nhiem hinh su; neu gay thiet hai thi phai boi thuong theo quy dinh cua phap luat: […] d) Lam ho so gia, vi pham quy che tuyen sinh, thi cu va cap van bang, chung chi.”
- Theo ong, neu khong su dung cac mang thiet bi quay bi mat vao phong thi thi lieu co cach nao khac co the to cao tieu cuc mot cach ro rang nhat va van dam bao quy che?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Theo toi van co cach de cac em khong vi pham quy che thi. Tuy nhien, cach do doi hoi thi sinh phai co ban linh hon.
Vi du, thi sinh co the yeu cau nhan vien hoi dong thi cham dut vi pham hoac phan anh voi chu tich hoi dong thi de lap bien ban va cham dut vi pham. Neu chu tich hoi dong thi khong giai quyet thi se phan anh len cap cao hon.
Tuy nhien, cac em da chon con duong rieng. Dieu do cung chung to cac em chua du tu tin va chua tin vao hoi dong, vao cong ly.
- Doi voi cac phong thi co de xay ra tinh trang gian lan nhu clip phan anh thi se phai xu ly nhu the nao thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Theo toi, phai huy ket qua thi. Xem doan video, toi thay cac em tap nap quay bai, chuyen dap an cho nhau, ban bac voi nhau tu nhien nhu cho khong nguoi thi toi nghi rang khong co may em la khong chep bai.
Tuy vay, van co the co thi sinh khong quay cop. De danh gia duoc chinh xac thi phai doi chieu bai lam cua thi sinh voi “phao” va thuc hien mot so bien phap ky thuat khac.
- Theo ong, can ap dung nhung bien phap nao de han che tieu cuc trong ky thi tot nghiep THPT?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Toi nghi rang Bo GD- DT, cac So GD-DT phai to chuc thanh tra, kiem tra, xu ly that nghiem. Chung ta chi can xu ly nghiem vai vu thoi thi se dau vao day. Con neu cu nuong nhe cho nhau thi sang nam lai nay ra nhung vu khac co khi con te hai hon.
Xin cam on ong!
Ban doc chia se ve suy nghi xung quanh viec thi sinh quay clip to cao tieu cuc thi tai truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo (Luc Nam, Bac Giang) xin gui vao o thao luan cuoi bai viet.
Pham Thinh ( thuc hien)
 |
| GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet cho rang nen khen ngoi hanh dong dung cam cua thi sinh quay clip tieu cuc tai Bac Giang (Anh: Pham Thinh) |
- Thua ong, khi xem clip ghi lai canh lon xon trong phong thi tai hoi dong thi truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo (Luc Nam, Bac Giang) vua qua, ong co suy nghi gi?
GS. Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Cac giam thi o hai phong thi da vi pham quy che thi mot cach nghiem trong. Viec dua dap an vao cho rat nhieu thi sinh nhu vay chung to day co kha nang la mot vu lam trai co to chuc.
Viec lam nay co the noi la rat dang xau ho, trong khi thi sinh nam nay lam de thi Van ban ve chu de doi tra, thi day la mot hanh dong doi tra trang tron, khong the nao chap nhan duoc.
- Thua ong, dua vao dau ong cho rang su viec lon xon vua qua tai hoi dong thi truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo co kha nang la co to chuc?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Neu khong co to chuc thi khong the lam nhu vay duoc. Phai co nguoi dua de ra ngoai, roi lam dap an, sau do pho to va chuyen hang chuc ban dap an vao phong cho thi sinh chep.
Vi vay, viec nay can phai xu ly nghiem. Truoc het, phai xu ly nhung nguoi truc tiep vi pham va lanh dao hoi dong thi. Tiep theo la xu ly lanh dao giao duc dia phuong, tu Phong GD huyen den So GD-DT.
- Thi sinh dem thiet bi quay vao phong thi ghi lai canh gian lan trong thi cu va to giac thi trong truong hop nay lieu co cong hay co toi, thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Viec hoc sinh mang thiet bi quay vao phong thi la vi pham quy che ro rang. Nhung chuyen gi cung vay, khi xu ly, phai xem xet “cong” va “toi”.
Ve cong, toi khen cac thi sinh do trung thuc va dung cam. Vi neu cac em cung im lang chep “phao” ma nguoi cua hoi dong thi dua vao thi cac em co the do, tham chi do voi diem cao.
Nhung cac em nay da khong chap nhan chuyen gian doi, da quay video va phan anh lai, nho do ma co quan quan ly giao duc biet duoc nhung sai pham dang dien ra de rut kinh nghiem chi dao nhung ky thi tiep theo.
- Giua cong va toi thi ben nao nang hon, thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Mang trang thiet bi trai phep vao phong thi thi bi dinh chi thi, tuc la khong duoc cong nhan ket qua thi cua mon thi co vi pham. Nhung ket qua thi cua cac thi sinh khac o hai phong thi nay cung kho co the duoc cong nhan.
Con viec cac em do neu bang chung to cao sai pham thi co loi cho cong tac giao duc chu khong co hai. Binh thuong, cong nay dang duoc khen thuong. Boi vay, viec xem xet truong hop nay phai het suc can nhac, khong the noi mot cach may moc, don gian duoc.
- Nhieu y kien cho rang, thiet bi quay cua thi sinh khong co chuc nang xem lai video, khong co thiet bi phat song vi vay khong the phuc vu cho loi ich cua thi sinh. Vay thiet bi nay co bi coi la mot thiet bi vi pham quy che khong thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Quy che thi da neu ro nhung thiet bi nao duoc phep mang vao phong thi. Mang nhung thiet bi khong duoc phep la vi pham quy che.
- Thua ong, neu nhung can bo va giam thi trong clip duoc xac dinh la to chuc giai de, nem bai cho thi sinh thi lieu day co phai la toi danh lam lo bi mat quoc gia?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Theo toi, day la hanh vi vi pham Luat Giao duc.
Khoan 2 Dieu 75 Luat Giao duc quy dinh mot trong nhung hanh vi nha giao khong duoc lam la “gian lan trong tuyen sinh, thi cu, co y danh gia sai ket qua hoc tap, ren luyen cua nguoi hoc”. Cac nhan vien duoc phan anh trong video clip da vi pham quy dinh nay.
Ve huong xu ly vi pham thi khoan 1 Dieu 118 Luat Giao duc da quy dinh ro: “Nguoi nao co mot trong cac hanh vi sau day thi tuy theo tinh chat, muc do vi pham ma bi xu ly ky luat, xu phat vi pham hanh chinh hoac truy cuu trach nhiem hinh su; neu gay thiet hai thi phai boi thuong theo quy dinh cua phap luat: […] d) Lam ho so gia, vi pham quy che tuyen sinh, thi cu va cap van bang, chung chi.”
- Theo ong, neu khong su dung cac mang thiet bi quay bi mat vao phong thi thi lieu co cach nao khac co the to cao tieu cuc mot cach ro rang nhat va van dam bao quy che?
 |
| Thi sinh ngang nghien quay bai trong phong thi tai truong THPT Doi Ngo (Luc Nam, Bac Giang) |
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Theo toi van co cach de cac em khong vi pham quy che thi. Tuy nhien, cach do doi hoi thi sinh phai co ban linh hon.
Vi du, thi sinh co the yeu cau nhan vien hoi dong thi cham dut vi pham hoac phan anh voi chu tich hoi dong thi de lap bien ban va cham dut vi pham. Neu chu tich hoi dong thi khong giai quyet thi se phan anh len cap cao hon.
Tuy nhien, cac em da chon con duong rieng. Dieu do cung chung to cac em chua du tu tin va chua tin vao hoi dong, vao cong ly.
- Doi voi cac phong thi co de xay ra tinh trang gian lan nhu clip phan anh thi se phai xu ly nhu the nao thua ong?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Theo toi, phai huy ket qua thi. Xem doan video, toi thay cac em tap nap quay bai, chuyen dap an cho nhau, ban bac voi nhau tu nhien nhu cho khong nguoi thi toi nghi rang khong co may em la khong chep bai.
Tuy vay, van co the co thi sinh khong quay cop. De danh gia duoc chinh xac thi phai doi chieu bai lam cua thi sinh voi “phao” va thuc hien mot so bien phap ky thuat khac.
- Theo ong, can ap dung nhung bien phap nao de han che tieu cuc trong ky thi tot nghiep THPT?
GS Nguyen Minh Thuyet: Toi nghi rang Bo GD- DT, cac So GD-DT phai to chuc thanh tra, kiem tra, xu ly that nghiem. Chung ta chi can xu ly nghiem vai vu thoi thi se dau vao day. Con neu cu nuong nhe cho nhau thi sang nam lai nay ra nhung vu khac co khi con te hai hon.
Xin cam on ong!
Ban doc chia se ve suy nghi xung quanh viec thi sinh quay clip to cao tieu cuc thi tai truong THPT Dan lap Doi Ngo (Luc Nam, Bac Giang) xin gui vao o thao luan cuoi bai viet.
Pham Thinh ( thuc hien)
Viet Bao
